Proofs of Evidence
Supporters Proofs of Evidence
Railfuture, Thames Valley Branch
SUPP/014/2
SUPP/014/3
Lord Bradshaw
SUPP/016/1
First Great Western
SUPP/20/1 Proof of evidence of First Great Western (original representation)
Bicester Vision
SUPP/025/1 Proof of evidence of Bicester Vision (original representation)
Oxford Airport
SUPP/026/1
Oxford United
SUPP/032/1 Proof of evidence of Oxford United (original representation)
Rail Freight Group
SUPP/038/1
Aylesbury Vale Advantage
SUPP/039/1 Proof of evidence of Aylesbury Vale Advantage (original representation)
Network Rail
SUPP/041/1
SUPP/041/2
Representors Proofs of Evidence
Jean Fooks
REP/7/2
Charlton on Otmoor Parish Council
REP/9/2
Oxford Presentation Trust
REP/11/2
REP/11/3
REP/11/4
REP/11/5
Cyclists Touring Club
REP12/2 Response to Chiltern's rebuttal proof of evidence by Philip Ashbourn on behalf of Cyclists Touring Club
REP12/3 Response to Chiltern's rebuttal proof of evidence by Dave Holladay on behalf of Cyclists Touring Club
Cherwell District Council
REP13/1 (Written Representation) 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6.
Objectors Proofs of Evidence
Ken Haywood
OBJ1/1 Proof of evidence of Ken Haywood (original representation)
OBJ1/2 Proof of evidence of Ken Haywood
Ian Salisbury
OBJ/005/2
OBJ/005/3
OBJ/005/4a Re-request for further information concerning the evidence submitted by Chiltern Railways dated 15 October 2010
OBJ/005/5
OBJ/005/6a Rebuttal proof to Stephen Barker
OBJ/005/6b Rebuttal proof to Richard Caten
OBJ/005/6c Rebuttal proof to Ian Gilder
OBJ/005/6d Rebuttal proof to Aiden Nelson
OBJ/005/7 Submission regarding the rights and privileges of the Freeman of Oxford over Port Meadow and the status of the Meadow as Common Land and its designation as a Special Area of Conservation dated 2 November 2010
OBJ5/8 Request for clarification of Chiltern's Railways' rebuttal proof of evidence
OBJ5/9 Rebuttal of the further evidence of Aiden Nelson - CRCL/P/7/E
OBJ5/12 Request for clarification of Chiltern's Railways' note to the Inspector on trap Ground Allotments Association Car Parking (CRCL/INQ/29)
OBJ5/19
OBJ5/23 Rebuttal by Ian Salisbury of the new evidence of Ian Gilder and Andrew Coates in relation to Oxford Meadows SAC - CRCL/INQ/72
Mrs G Walker
OBJ/007/2
OBJ/007/3/1 Supplementary proof of evidence by Robert Thompson on behalf of Mrs Greta Walker
OBJ/007/6/1 Application for costs made under Department of Transport Circular 3/94
Drs Michael Drolet and Rosalind Thomas
OBJ009/1 Proof of evidence of Dr and Mrs Drolet (original representation)
Mr and Mrs West
OBJ012/1 Proof of evidence of Mr and Mrs West (original representation)
Trap Ground Allotments Association
OBJ/013/2
OBJ/013/4 Email exchange between Mr Hollander and Oxford City Council regarding the lease of the Allotments
Beth A Forrow
OBJ/026/1 (Written Representation)
Gosford and Water Eaton Parish Council
OBJ/033/1
OBJ/033/2
OBJ033/9 Letter dated 21 December 2010 from Gosford and Water Eaton Parish Council to the Programme Officer
OBJ033/10 Letter dated 5 January 2011 from Gosford and Water Eaton Parish Council to the Programme Officer
OBJ033/12 Letter dated 27 January 2011 from Gosford and Water Eaton Parish Council to the Programme Officer setting out their concluding remarks
Dr Ian Eaast
OBJ34/1W Written representation of Dr Ian East
Mr Michael Graham & Mrs Amanda Roberts
OBJ/039/2
Ramblers Association
OBJ/041/2
M & J & J Honour
OBJ/044/2-045/2-046/1
James & Lucy De Jonge
OBJ/050/1
Birch Sites Limited
OBJ/053/2 (Written Representation)
Oxford Fieldpaths Society
OBJ/055/2
South Central Ambulance Service
OBJ/063/2
McKay Securities PLC
OBJ/066/2-1
OBJ/066/2-2
OBJ/066/3-1
OBJ/066/3-2
OBJ/066/3-3
OBJ/066/4-1
OBJ/066/4-2
OBJ66/4-3 Summary proof of evidence of Gregory Beale on behalf of McKay Securities plc
OBJ/066/5-1
OBJ/066/5-2
OBJ66/5-3 Summary proof of evidence of Neil Warner on behalf of McKay Securities plc
John & Jane Delafield
OBJ/075/1
Mr Thorowgood and Ms Chance
OBJ/077/2
North Oxford Golf Club
OBJ/085/2
Mr P Napier
OBJ/088/2
OBJ/088/3 Letter dated 9 November 2010 from Mr P Napier to the Inspector setting out the latest position
Merry Adams
OBJ90/1 Proof of evidence of Merry Adams (original representation)
Mr & Mrs J Conibear
OBJ/091/2
OBJ/091/4
Dr & Mrs S Young
OBJ/095/2
Marianne Julebin
OBJ97/1 Proof of evidence of Marianne Julebin (original representation)
Mr Henry Horton
OBJ/098/3
OBJ/098/4
David R. Davies
OBJ/100/1 (Written Representation)
Hanson Quarry Products Europe Limited
OBJ/101/2
OBJ101/4 Supplementary statement of Paul Williams on behalf of Hanson Quarry Products Europe Ltd
Grundon Waste Management Limited
OBJ/102/2
OBJ/102/3
OBJ/102/4
Worcester College
OBJ/108/2
Oxford City Council
OBJ/109/2 (Written Representation)
OBJ/109/3 Written representation by David Radford, Archaeologist, Oxford City Council
OBJ109/4W Letter dated 15 November 2010 from Oxford City Council responding to CRCL/P/12/E
Brian Davies
OBJ/111/1 Proof of evidence of Brian Davies (original representation)
Mr Luciano & Mrs Christine Howard, Mr Peter and Mrs Andriana Farr
OBJ/117/1-118/1
Oxford Green Belt Network
OBJ/122/2
Mr Sean Feeney
OBJ123/2 Report to Oxford City Council by David Fenton & Stephen J Pratt dated 21 December 2010
OBJ123/3 Undated Core Document for Oxford Core Strategy - Joint statement from Oxford City Council, Natural England and Berkshire, Buckinghamshire and Oxfordshire Wildlife Trust.
OBJ123/4 Submission by the Berkshire, Buckinghamshire and Oxfordshire Wildlife Trust to the Oxford Core Strategy, Matter 8 Strategic Locations, 22 June 2009
OBJ123/5 Natura 2000 Standard Data Form - Oxford Meadows
OBJ123/7 NBN Gateway - Species records at 10km or better that fall within or overlap Oxford Meadows (SAC)
OBJ123/8 Guidance document on Article 6(4) of the Habitats Directive 92/43/EEC
Oxfordshire County Council
OBJ131/2 Proof of David Taylor
OBJ131/3 Proof of Richard Olam
OBJ131/6 Letter dated 13 January 2011 on behalf of Oxfordshire County Council in respect of the Council's land ownership
Mrs M Rosenberg
OBJ/143/2
Sir Muir & Lady Jaqueline Gray
OBJ/149/1
Robert Hope
OBJ179/1 Proof of evidence of Robert Hope (original representation)
OBJ179/2 Proof of evidence of Robert Hope
Mr Mark Howard
OBJ/184/2
Mr & Mrs G Honour
OBJ/185/2
Topbreed Limited
OBJ/189/2 Proof of evidence of Kerry Clarke on behalf of Topbreed Limited
OBJ/189/3 Summary proof of evidence of Kerry Clarke on behalf of Topbreed Limited
OBJ189/4 Rebuttal proof of evidence of Kerry Clarke on behalf of Topbreed Limited
OBJ189/7 Topbreed response to CRCL/INQ/34 and CRCL/INQ/34/1
OBJ189/7a Topbreed response to CRCL/INQ/34 and CRCL/INQ/34/1 and re-dated version of OBJ189/7
Primepark Ltd
OBJ/190/2 Proof of evidence of Kerry Clarke on behalf of Primepark Limited
OBJ/190/3 Summary proof of evidence of Kerry Clarke on behalf of Primepark Limited
OBJ190/4 Rebuttal proof of evidence of Kerry Clarke on behalf of Primepark Limited
The Owners and Residents of Merton Grounds Farm
OBJ/191/2 Proof of evidence by Dick van Wijngaarden on behalf of the owners and residents of Merton Grounds Farm
OBJ/191/3 Appendices to proof of evidence by Dick van Wijngaarden on behalf of the owners and residents of Merton Grounds Farm
OBJ/191/4 Summary proof of evidence by Dick van Wijngaarden on behalf of the owners and residents of Merton Grounds Farm
OBJ191/5 Rebuttal proof of evidence of Richard Caten by Dick van Wijngaarden on behalf of the owners and residents of Merton Grounds Farm
OBJ191/6 Rebuttal proof of evidence of Ian Gilder by Dick van Wijngaarden on behalf of the owners and residents of Merton Grounds Farm
OBJ191/7 Rebuttal proof of evidence of Aiden Nelson by Dick van Wijngaarden on behalf of the owners and residents of Merton Grounds Farm
OBJ191/8 Route Maps
OBJ191/9 Errata to Route Maps
OBJ191/10 Purpose and point in evidence for site visit
OBJ191/11 Traffic survey at Langford Lane
The Calcutt Trustees
OBJ/194/2 Proof of evidence of Graham Candy on behalf of the Calcutt Trustees
CPRE Oxfordshire
OBJ/195/2 Proof of evidence by Alan Jones on behalf of CPRE Oxfordshire Branch
OBJ/195/3 Summary proof of evidence by Alan Jones on behalf of CPRE Oxfordshire Branch
Bus Users UK, Oxford Branch
OBJ/205/1A Proof of evidence of Hugh Jeager on behalf of Bus Users UK Oxford Branch
OBJ/205/2 Map of bus links with rail passenger catchment areas
OBJ/205/3 Map of stoppages and diversions of public rights of way
OBJ/205/4 Summary proof of evidence of Hugh Jeager on behalf of Bus Users UK Oxford Branch
Berks Bucks & Oxon Wildlife Trust
OBJ/211/2 Proof of evidence of Rebecca Micklem of Berks, Bucks and Oxon Wildlife Trust
OBJ/211/3 Summary proof of evidence of Rebecca Micklem of Berks, Bucks and Oxon Wildlife Trust
OBJ211/5/APP/1a Appendix - letter dated 10 April 1989 re access to Wendlebury Meads
OBJ211/5/APP/1b Appendix - letter dated 28 July 1988 from Oxfordshire County Council re access track at Charlton-on-Otmoor
OBJ211/5/APP/1c Appendix - letter dated 28 July 1988 from Oxfordshire County Council re access track at Charlton-on-Otmoor, page 2
OBJ211/5/APP/1d Appendix - plan Lot 5, Mill Farm, Charlton-on-Otmoor
OBJ211/5/APP/1e Appendix - Tender document for sale of 9.37 acres of Agricultural Land at Mansmoor Road
OBJ211/5/APP/1f Appendix - Tender document for sale of 9.37 acres of Agricultural Land at Mansmoor Road, part 2
OBJ211/6/APP/2 Appendix - Official Land Registry copy of Title
OBJ211/6/APP/2a Appendix - Official Land Registry copy of Title ON 124421
Lewis & Sarah Butler
OBJ/212/2
Rosemary Harris
OBJ/213/2 Proof of evidence of Rosemary Harris
OBJ/213/3 Appendix to proof of evidence of Rosemary Harris
OBJ213/4 Further questions of clarification on behalf of Rosemary Harris
OBJ213/5 Email exchange between Mr Withrington and Mr Eyles
OBJ213/6 Opening and Rebuttal for Rosemary Harris
British Waterways Board
OBJ/214/2 Proof of evidence by Jeff Whyatt on behalf of British Waterways Board
OBJ/214/3 Summary proof of evidence by Jeff Whyatt on behalf of British Waterways Board
OBJ/214/4 Appendices to proof of evidence by Jeff Whyatt on behalf of British Waterways Board
Mr & Mrs Unwin
OBJ/222/2
OBJ/222/3 - Appendices
OBJ/222/4 - Summary Proof of Evidence
Francis, Jennifer & James Shouler
OBJ/225/2
Catherine & Bartholemew Quinn
OBJ/230/1
Ms C Robertson
OBJ/234/2
OBJ234/4 Rebuttal proof of evidence of Dr C Robertson
OBJ234/6 Summary Proof of evidence of Dr C Robertson as read out at the Inquiry
OBJ234/10 Noise levels, modelling, monitoring, mitigation, Government policy and CRCL/INQ/32
Sushila Dhall
OBJ/235/2
Mr J Clark
OBJ/236/3 Email from Mr J Clark to the Programme Officer dated 10 November 2010 regarding parking at the gates of the allotments
OBJ236/4 Rebuttal of CRCL/INQ/29 by Mr J Clark
OBJ236/5 Email from Mr J Clark to the Programme Officer dated 4 January 2011 regarding Conditions
Messrs Offord & Bradshaw
OBJ/238/2
OBJ/238/3
OBJ/238/4
OBJ238/7 Rebuttal of CRCL/INQ/53
Mr Paul Miller
OBJ/241/2
OBJ/241/3
OBJ/241/4
Mr T Howard
OBJ/242/2A
OBJ/242/2B
OBJ242/3 Written representation of Mr T P Howard
Mr A Buckley
OBJ/245/2
Natural England
OBJ/246/2
OBJ/246/3
OBJ/246/4 Natural England's Advice on Bat Mitigation Plan (Version 2) dated 2 November 2010
OBJ246/6 Position statement by Natural England's in response to CRCL/INQ/48, CRCL/INQ/60 and CRCL/INQ/61
J J Gallagher Ltd
OBJ/249/2 (Written Representation)
PM Claye
OBJ/255/1
OBJ/255/2 Further proof of evidence of Peter Claye
OBJ255/3 Letter dated 22 January from Peter Claye to Ian Gilder
Wendlebury Parish Council
OBJ/286/1 Proof of evidence of Wendlebury Parish Council
DB Schenker Rail (UK) Ltd
OBJ/293/2 Proof of evidence of David Bryett, DB Schenker Rail (OK) Limited
OBJ293/3 Rebuttal proof of evidence of DB Schenker Rail (UK) Limited
Islip Parish Council
OBJ/294/1 Proof of evidence by Richard Venables on behalf of Islip PC
Professor Korsunsky
OBJ/295/2 Proof of evidence of Professor Korsunsky
OBJ295/3 Rebuttal proof of evidence of Professor Korsunsky
OBJ295/5 Train-track-soil-vibration interactions
OBJ295/4
OBJ293/4 Plan of new Water Eaton Parkway Station relocated Stone Sidings
Engage Oxford
OBJ/297/2
OBJ297/4 Presentation of verbal summary by Engage Oxford
Kidlington Parish Council
OBJ/311/2
Nicola Blackwood MP
OBJ/312/1
SS Philip and James School
OBJ/313/1 (Written Representation)
Freeman of Oxford and Port Meadow Protection Group
OBJ314/1 Proof of evidence of Freeman of Oxford and Port Meadow Protection Group
OBJ314/1b Summary Statement of 15th December 2010 on behalf of the Freemen of Oxford and the Port Meadow Protection Group
OBJ314/2 Rebuttal note on behalf of the Freeman of Oxford and Port Meadow Protection Group
Mr E Surridge
OBJ315/1 Proof of evidence of Edward Surridge
Jordan Hill Residents' Association
OBJ/316/1 Written representation of Jordan Hill Residents' Association
Paul Withrington
OBJ319/1 Proof of evidence of Paul Withrington
OBJ319/2 Errata sheet to Proof of evidence of Paul Withrington, received 3 January 2011
OBJ319/3 Response of Mr P Withrington to Chiltern Railway Rebuttal Proof CRCL/R/OBJ319
OBJ319/4 Supplementary evidence and response of Mr P Withrington to Chiltern Railway Rebuttal Proof CRCL/R/OBJ319
OBJ319/5 Article for the Railway Technology Magazine, author Mr P Withrington
OBJ319/6 Summary of Statement of Case of Paul Withrington6
OBJ319/7 Map of Oxford area
OBJ319/8 Chiltern Railway's Accounts for the year ending January 2010
OBJ319/9 Supplementary evidence following cross examination, Paul Withrington
OBJ319/10 Supplementary evidence in preparation for closing, Paul Withrington
OBJ319/11 Supplementary evidence- train times in preparation for closing, Paul Withrington
OBJ319/13 Supplementary evidence- Paul Withrington
Peter and Carol Jarvis
OBJ320/1W Written representation of Peter and Carol Jarvis
Wolvercote Commoners
OBJ321/1 Proof of evidence of Wolvercote Commoners
The Friends of the Trap Grounds
OBJ322/1W Written representation of The Friends of the Trap Grounds
Dr Corri Waitt
OBJ323/1W Written representation of Dr Corri Waitt